Reaction Web

Search REACTION projects Search REACTION projects

Map REACTION projects Map REACTION projects


Judgedments

VIII. EXPERT JUDGEMENT

1. Expert contact (person who fills the expert judgement):
Expert Contact same as Project Contact? Yes
Expert Contact same as Data Contact? Yes
If expert contact is different from Data and Project contact, please indicate: 
Last Name:   First Name:  
Organisation:   Job Title:  
Street Address:   City:   
State:    Postal code:  
Phone:   Fax number:  
Email:    Web page Address:   
Relationship with the project: 
- Design
- Implementation
- Management of project area
- Research
- Other (describe):  

2. According to site conditions and degradation impacts, were the objectives appropriate and well-chosen?
Yes
Explain briefly: Nowadays, retaining the soil to avoid floodings in the nearest towns is as important as before. That is what prompts managers to think of other objectives to improve the forest situation. 

3. According to site conditions and degradation impacts, were the methods (site preparation, species selection, prior actions,...) appropiate and well-chosen?
Yes
Explain briefly: The technique has been improved since the project was made. Nowadays the cost and number of gaps would have been lower. However, the methods were the best ones that existed a century ago.  

4. Do ecological health and integrity appear to be improved, enhanced?
Yes
Explain briefly: Since the complexity has been increased 

5. Does the general ecological trajectory appear dynamic?
Yes
Explain briefly: Vegetation evolved from Thymus and Stipa tenacissima to a pine forest, where there exists regeneration and a tree strata with pines, oaks and riparian vegetation. 

6. Any signs of threshold crossings?
No
Explain briefly:  

7. Consequences of the restoration project on the soil (physical properties, biological activities, functions,...):
The amount of organic matter was higher; this activated the nutrient cycles and improved the chemical and physical characteristics of the soil.  

8. Consequences on ecosystem structure, including forest cover, horizontal layers, etc. :
Horizontal and vertical structure have been diversified. 

9. Consequences on ecosystem functions : productivity, dissemination, etc. :
Higher productivity and higher and better dissemination 

10. Actions needed and next monitoring actions to be considered. Please explain in your own words and indicate your recommendations, e.g., for
a.- Research/Development: New methods to increase biodiversity in the forest: species, structure... 
b.- Demonstration, communication and education: To show tourists how a forest has been traditionally managed  
c.- Public policy: More resources for the rural population who own the lands that must be protected  
d.- Other:   

REACTION: This research is supported by the "Energy, Environment and Sustainable Development" programme, under contract EVK2-2002-80025